The technology secretary has come out in support of a debated part of the Online Safety Bill that would obligate messaging applications to disclose the material of private messages when requested by Ofcom, the regulatory body.
She declared that it was a prudent approach to shield minors from mistreatment.
Yet some tech firms, such as WhatsApp and Signal, have warned that they may have to move out of the UK if a means is created to access their secure messaging.
The Bill is expected to be enacted in the fall.
Michelle Donelan spoke with the BBC during her visit to University College London and declared the allocation of £13m for Artificial Intelligence ventures in healthcare.
The tech industry and the cyber security field have voiced disapproval of the government's proposition that encrypted messages should be made available if there is a possibility that children are in danger from their contents.
Messages delivered using this method can only be viewed by the sender and the receiver, preventing tech companies from having access to them.
Popular messaging services such as Whatsapp by Meta and iMessage by Apple utilize this widely-used security feature by default.
However, when the access route is found, not only the good guys will use it, with some companies declaring that they will remove their services from the UK totally, rather than agree to weaken security.
Ms Donelan asserted that the government was not averse to encryption and would only petition for access as a final alternative.
"Just like you, I value privacy since I would not appreciate people perusing my intimate messages. They would be highly unentertained, but I do not wish for them to do that," she declared.
Despite this, we recognize that these platforms can also be powerful tools for good."
Although we are aware that certain online platforms occasionally become a source of child abuse and sexual exploitation, we acknowledge that they may also be employed as effective means for positive outcomes.
"We need to be able to access that data should the issue arise."
She also stated that tech businesses would be responsible for investing in technology to address this problem.
Technology is being created to allow you to have encryption, and to be able to access the data and the safety protocol is very specific that it can only be used for child exploitation and abuse.
Client Side Scanning is the leading option right now, involving the installation of software onto devices to scan content and issue alerts. This approach encountered opposition, leading Apple to stop a trial, and earning it the nickname "the spy in your pocket".
When it comes to the technology, Ryan Polk, the Director of Internet Policy at the Internet Society, is not very confident. The Internet Society, a charitable non profit organization that focuses on Internet regulation, tech, and development, holds his view.
He declared that the government's Safety Tech Challenge Fund, which was anticipated to locate a miraculous technical solution to this issue, was not successful.
Mr Polk stated that researchers from the National Research Centre on Privacy, Harm Reduction and Adversarial Influence Online had identified considerable issues with the technologies proposed, "including that they would compromise the end-to-end security and privacy essential for safeguarding the safety and privacy of British citizens." He went on to express that if the UK government fails to acknowledge that the Online Safety Bill would essentially forbid encryption, then they are deliberately avoiding perceiving the risks in the future.
It is anticipated that the legislation will be returned to the House of Commons in September.
Comments